A young woman sues her mother’s doctor for the strangest reason


T + NS – normal size

A young British woman has complained to her mother’s doctor in court, claiming that he caused her to give birth, which was not supposed to happen.

Evie Tumbes, 20, of Skegness, Lincolnshire, is suing her mother’s GP for millions of dollars in damages, saying her birth would not have occurred without the doctor’s mistake.

Effie was born with spina bifida, a condition in which a fetus’s spine and spinal cord fail to develop in the womb, leaving a gaping hole in the spine, causing her to spend some days with tubes 24 hours a day.

Despite her condition, Evie has worked her way up to work in show jumping, competing against disabled riders, as well as appearing on ITV’s “Hidden Disabilities: What’s the Truth” and winning a charity event in 2018.

Ivy says Dr. Philip Mitchell is responsible for the false pregnancy, after he failed to advise her mother, Caroline Tombs, to take the pre-pregnancy probiotic.

Effie asserts that if her mother’s doctor had advised her to take folic acid supplements to reduce the chance of her fetus developing spina bifida, her mother would not have become pregnant and had not yet given birth. But Dr. Mitchell denies the allegations, saying he has given Mrs. Tombis “reasonable advice”.

The Supreme Court heard how 50-year-old Ms Tombies went to visit Dr. Mitchell at Hawthorne Medical Center in Skegness to explain her plans for having her first child in February 2001, and Eve’s attorney, Susan Rodway QC, told the court how Ms Tombs was anxious to start a family. After she lost her parents.

But despite discussing folic acid during the consultation, Ms. Tombs insists that Dr. Mitchell did not tell her about its importance in preventing spina bifida, and Ms. Rodway says that had Ms Tombs been adequately advised by her GP, she would not have proceeded with her pregnancy in such a hurry as She did, and had her pregnancy been delayed, she would have given birth to a “normal, healthy” baby.

But Dr. Mitchell denied all the allegations, with his attorney, Michael de Navarro, insisting he had given “reasonable advice” about wanting folic acid supplements, and it was his common practice to tell mothers to take 400 micrograms during the first trimester of pregnancy. He claims that he would have certainly advised the mother to follow a good diet with good levels of folic acid, and denied that supplementation was not necessary.

The court also heard that Effie’s ability to move is very limited, and she will need a wheelchair as she gets older and has problems with her intestines and bladder. Despite her circumstances, Evie still teaches children about unseen diseases and works at the University of Nottingham.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here